Skip to main content

Fair Use or Free Ride? The YouTube Music Hustle


Fair Use or Free Ride? The YouTube Music Hustle





YouTube Copyright Strike


Let’s get one thing straight: I would love to be able to make short videos with popular music soundtracks. Who wouldn’t? Drop a Van Halen riff, a James Brown groove, or a Beyoncé hook under a clip and boom—instant vibe. But here’s the problem: copyright law doesn’t care about your vibe.

And honestly? I get it. That music doesn’t belong to me. It doesn’t even fully belong to the artists most of the time. It belongs to the record label—the machine that holds the rights. If I want to use it, I have to play by the rules or face the takedown hammer.

But here’s where my beef comes in.

Some YouTubers build entire channels around playing pieces of popular songs under the banner of “fair use.” They’ll play a guitar intro here, a vocal lick there, and talk about why it’s great. The pitch is: “I’m educating. I’m reviewing. I’m safe under fair use.”

Except now, those same creators are crying foul because YouTube is cracking down. Some are facing copyright claims and even threats of losing their channels.

One guy in particular—he’s on video lamenting that a 40-second short of his only made $36 before it got flagged. Thirty-six bucks. He could just take the video down and protect his whole channel. But nope—he’d rather fight for that “principle.”

And I’m sitting here thinking: Really, dude? That $36 is your hill to die on?

Meanwhile, he’s pumping out multiple shorts a week, all built on the backs of legendary artists who poured blood, sweat, and tears into the music he’s cutting up. And let’s be real—most of those artists got chewed up by the record labels already.

So now, on top of all that, some YouTuber comes along, plays their work, monetizes it, and pockets guaranteed money just because the artist is popular. And he doesn’t share a dime.

I can’t muster sympathy. Sorry, not sorry.

Here’s my take: if you want to make money off YouTube—

  • Get a job like the rest of us did.
  • Or join the club of creators who’d love to use popular music but can’t because we respect the consequences.
  • Or if you’re really a badass—make original music. Show us something we’ve never heard before.

Because at the end of the day, what’s being defended isn’t “fair use.” It’s a free ride.

And I’ll admit it—I’d love to take that free ride, too. Easy money off the hard work of others sounds great. But I know better. And if you’ve built your whole channel on someone else’s art, maybe it’s time you know better too.


Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Welcome to the Darkside of the Johnny: The Journey Begins

H ey, rockers and rollers, it's Darkside Johnny here, and yes, I might have just turned my 'About Page' into a bit of an accidental first post (thanks, Mary Jane, for the inspiration). But hey, in the spirit of rock 'n' roll, let’s roll with the punches. So, here we are, officially kicking off Darkside Johnny Rocks . The journey of a thousand miles starts with a single step, or in my case, a slightly misdirected leap. But that's rock for you — it’s unpredictable, a little chaotic, and always unexpected. What's Up Next? • The Guitar Experiment: I'll be sharing my journey back to the fretboard. Will the muscle memory kick in? Can my new theory make guitar playing easier for everyone? Watch this space for updates, and maybe, just maybe, some embarrassing re-learning moments. • Rock Tales : From the tales of bands like Led Zeppelin, who I swear once caused a tsunami of groupies with just one riff, to the time I saw The Who and thought my eardrums had...
Post a Comment
Read more

What Is Perfection? A Midnight Meditation for the Broken-In Guitar Souls

Midnight Meditations 🎸 What Is Perfection? A Midnight Meditation for the Broken-In Guitar Souls By Darkside Johnny Perfection. People throw that word around like it’s a destination — like there’s a road that leads to some spotless, scratch-free mountaintop where the music is flawless and the angels tune your strings. But that ain’t Rock ’n’ Roll . Rock was born half-drunk, off-key, heartbroken, unapologetic, and barefoot on a barroom floor. It wasn’t meant to be pretty. It was meant to be true . Perfection Is a Ghost Try to grab perfection and it slips right through your fingers. It’s not a standard — it’s a shadow cast by intention. When you care enough to hit the truth dead-center, sometimes you brush up against perfection… but nobody lives in it. Musicians don’t chase perfection. They chase moments — those rare, electric seconds when everything inside you says yes . Beauty? That’s a Different Beast. If beauty really lives in the eye of the beholder, then nobody ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Let's Get Horny

Let's Get Horny 🎺🎸 Guitar + Brass Jam Masterclass Sometimes, a guitar alone just isn’t enough to get your session sizzling. Adding brass instruments is like adding spices to a killer riff — suddenly everything comes alive. But it’s not just about slapping a trumpet on your chord progression; knowing the theory makes the magic happen. Playing Saxophone Parts On Guitar 1. Scales & Modes for Maximum Horn Chemistry Guitar Scale / Mode Sound Horn Application Why It Works Minor Pentatonic / Blues Gritty, raw Horns echo riffs or add blue notes Perfect for call-and-response solos; gritty, soulful, rock-blues flavor Dorian (Minor with natural 6th) Funky, jazzy Horns improvise with extensions Adds optimism and spice to minor riffs, great for funky or soulful jams Mixolydian (Major with b7) Bluesy, ...
Post a Comment
Read more